Tuesday, February 4 Updated: March 8, 2:41 PM ET Milwaukee Brewers By John Sickels Special to ESPN.com |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
2002 in review
What went wrong? Jeffrey Hammonds and Glendon Rusch were frustratingly inconsistent, while Ruben Quevedo and Jamey Wright were just plain awful. Hernandez struck out 188 times and was only saved from setting a strikeout record by Royster's refusal to play him in the final days. GM Dean Taylor was canned in September, while Brewers president Wendy Selig-Prieb resigned. New GM Doug Melvin decided not to retain Royster. Although the rookie manager could hardly be blamed for all that went wrong, he took the news well. "I'd fire me, too" was Royster's comment.
In retrospect, the critical decisions were:
2. Giving up, though this was done in stages. When it became obvious that the team was going nowhere under his leadership, Lopes was dumped. When that didn't work, Taylor fully committed to a youth movement and started to ship off veterans for prospects. It was the right thing to do, although force-feeding unready kids like Bill Hall, Ben Diggins, Dave Pember, and Matt Childers late in the season was done for publicity reasons according to critics, and could have a negative impact on their development. 3. Did Nick Neugebauer have any business making 12 starts? He was rehabbing from injury, and his control is still awful. Sticking him in Triple-A would have been a more prudent course of action. Granted, he was actually one of the more effective Milwaukee starters, posting a 4.72 ERA, but the Brewers would have lost 100 games with or without him, and the move could be a long-term backfire, if only because it burned service time.
Looking ahead to 2003 The downside of this is that Melvin must avoid the temptation to continue shipping in retread vets if the current ones actually play well. Patching a hole with a vet is defensible expedient, if temporary. Over-reliance on guys like Clayton and Ritchie is suicidal in the long run for a team like the Brewers. If they do play well, trading them to a contender for prospects later in the season must be a priority. Dave Mlicki and John Vander Wal, also free agent signees, are in the same category. 2. Can they get use out of "free talent." Melvin made a nifty little trade with Minnesota this winter, picking up pitcher Matt Kinney and catcher Javier Valentin, excess talent on the Twins roster, for a pair of A-ball pitchers. Both could play significant roles, Kinney especially. Outfielder Brady Clark, picked up on waivers, could be a solid reserve outfielder, and free agent signee Chuck Smith has had his moments of success in the majors. Mining talent like this will be a key for the rebuilding project; it's something that the successful small and medium-revenue teams have learned to do. 3. New manager Ned Yost. Long-time Milwaukee fans are familiar with him as a reserve catcher and 1982 pennant contributor. This is his first major league managerial job, and all the normal questions have to be answered: how will he handle the pitching staff? The lineup? The clubhouse? Will he throw things at reporters? Etc.
Can expect to play better
Can expect to play worse
Projected lineup
Rotation
Closer
A closer look Of the holdover hitters, Richie Sexson and Geoff Jenkins are certainly capable of increasing their output. Jeffrey Hammonds is dicier, but if healthy he could hit closer to his career .795 OPS rather than the .729 mark he put up last year. Still not outstanding, but a little better. The problem here is that any improvement from this trio is likely to be cancelled out by the replacement of Jose Hernandez with Royce Clayton, or possibly a decline from an aging Eric Young. Of the new faces, Javier Valentin has more offensive ability than the man he replaces, Paul Bako. He's an adequate hitter, as opposed to a poor one. New third baseman Wes Helms, over from Atlanta, replaces the Lenny Harris/Tyler Houston/Mark Loretta/Ron Belliard combination from last year. Brewers third basemen hit .279/.342/.414 in '02. Helm's career marks are .234/.287/.423. Granted, playing full time will likely help him do better, but it's entirely possible that Helms won't be any better than the old combo. And as mentioned above, Clayton is not nearly the hitter Hernandez is. The new faces don't represent a major upgrade. The pitching staff could be better, if Todd Ritchie rebounds, and if the Brewers get something out of Dave Mlicki, and if rookies like Ben Diggins and Wayne Franklin contribute, and if Neugebauer is healthy. And even if some of those ifs come true, the bullpen will have to hold up, otherwise improvements in the rotation would be counteracted by a decline in relief. Are the Brewers doomed to another 100-loss season? Of course not. We're not trying to be overly negative here. Even average work out of some of the new faces and a slight improvement from the holdovers will help. The point is that there is no quick fix to the situation in Milwaukee. This is a multi-year rebuilding effort. Good years from the current roster will get the record closer to .500, but barring some spectacular development, getting past that will be very difficult with the current group. In the long run, the key will be building the farm system. Former general manager Dean Taylor's administration made a good start at that, and current GM Doug Melvin had a good farm track record in Texas. Milwaukee fans should place their hopes for the future not in the Royce Claytons of the world, but in the Mike Joneses and Brad Nelsons. Hopefully, the Brewers front office has the same perspective. John Sickels is the author of the 2002 Minor League Scouting Notebook, and is now working on the 2003 Baseball Prospect Book. His biography of Bob Feller will be published next spring. He lives in Lawrence, Kansas, with his wife, son, and two cats. You can send John questions or comments at JASickels@aol.com, or you can visit his homepage at JohnSickels.com. |
|