Yankees vs. A's | Mariners vs. White Sox | Braves vs. Cardinals | Mets vs. Giants
Monday, October 9
Five questions: Braves vs. Cardinals
By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

1. Which team is helped by the extra day off?
Because the TV people want three games to televise Tuesday, the Braves and Cardinals are this year's winners of the bizarre every-other-day scheduling format for the first three games.

Greg Maddux
St. Louis could see Greg Maddux twice in a five-game series.

They play Tuesday, are off Wednesday, play Thursday, are off Friday and then finish the series by playing three days in a row, if necessary.

The Cardinals had to play a division series under that format in 1996 -- and swept the Padres. The Braves have never done it. Still, no team stands to benefit more from this schedule than Atlanta.

Because of the extra off day, the Braves would get to pitch Greg Maddux (Games 1 and 4) and Tom Glavine (Games 2 and 5) in four of the five games, on normal rest. And when those two started this year, the Braves played .643 baseball (45-25). When anyone else started, their winning percentage was exactly 100 points lower (50-42, .543).

"You'd have to give the pitching edge to Maddux and Glavine," said an NL scout. "And the way they've been pitching of late, I've never seen the two of them pitch so well together."

So the erratic back end of their rotation will need to contribute just one start -- most likely by Kevin Millwood in Game 3.

Meanwhile, if the Cardinals have any starting-pitching edge in this series -- and that's dubious -- it would be the depth of their rotation. But that won't come into play in this series.

"Darryl Kile," said one scout, "is the big man in this series for St. Louis." Kile won't pitch the first game, however, manager Tony La Russa announced Monday.

2. How much will the Cardinals miss Mike Matheny?
He might not seem like the most magical name on that Cardinals roster, but when Mike Matheny ended his season by being a little too careless opening his birthday presents last week, he inflicted a very damaging blow to his team.

Matheny threw out a Pudge-esque 53 percent of the unenlightened opponents who tried to steal a base on him this season. And no other starting catcher in the National League even threw out 40 percent.

His replacement, Carlos Hernandez, nailed only 28 percent (7 of 25). And that could play right into the hands of a Braves team that was second in the league in steals -- but stole just four bases in six tries in seven games against St. Louis this year.

"Matheny, to me, was the heart and soul of that defense," said an NL scout. "They don't need his bat. But he led that pitching staff all year. So losing him really hurts them."

3. Rocker vs. Veres
We started this Braves season talking about John Rocker. We ended this season talking about Rocker. For different reasons, fortunately.

But once the Braves proved they could play over the Sally Jesse Raphael portion of the Rocker sideshow, all that mattered -- all that has ever mattered -- is whether this guy could get the 27th out in a big game.

Suddenly, after Sunday, there are doubts again about whether he can do that. Before Chipper Jones' error that opened the door for a seven-run Colorado ninth, Rocker hadn't been scored on since Aug. 22 (10 2/3 IP, 17 SO). He'd given up a run in only five of his previous 25 outings (25 IP, 18 H, 26 SO). And he'd walked just one hitter since Aug. 16 (15 appearances).

Then that Jeff Cirillo ground ball skipped off Chipper's glove. Rocker turned it into a seven-run inning. And now he has to head into the playoffs under a whole new glare of big-time scrutiny.

"No matter how good his numbers look, he's not the Rocker of last year," said one scout. "As cocky as he might act, all this other stuff has hurt him. Every time he goes to a new city, he's got to battle all the elements -- off the field, just going to the field, for that matter. And to me, I still think it's taken away from his concentration."

But his counterpart, Dave Veres, is also a question mark. Veres was scored on in four of his last 13 appearances and has had only one 1-2-3 save since the All-Star break. So while he has gotten the job done (29 for 36), the game isn't over just because he walks out of the bullpen.

"Of all the closers in the playoffs," said one scout, "Veres is the one guy who isn't in the top echelon. He's too unpredictable. He would scare me going into a game that big."

4. Will Big Mac contribute?
All those years of waiting for this moment, and now, with a chance to walk back onto the October stage, Mark McGwire is forced to turn into Dave Hansen.

He may be the scariest pinch-hitter on any team's bench. But he's still just a cameo player -- and the Cardinals have to be careful how they use him.

Just his presence, when he steps up to the plate, puts a little fear in any pitcher. But it's to your advantage to pitch around him, because if he gets on first, they have to use two players every time he gets into a game, because they have to use somebody to pinch-run for him. They did it all of September, and with the expanded rosters, that was no problem. But it can be a problem in October.
NL scout, on Mark McGwire

"Just his presence, when he steps up to the plate, puts a little fear in any pitcher," said an NL scout. "But it's to your advantage to pitch around him, because if he gets on first, they have to use two players every time he gets into a game, because they have to use somebody to pinch-run for him. They did it all of September, and with the expanded rosters, that was no problem. But it can be a problem in October."

So the Cardinals will almost have to save McGwire for home-run situations only. And incredibly, of all the members of the 500-homer club who got more than 50 postseason at-bats, McGwire has the third-worst home-run ratio (4 HR, 114 AB, one every 28.5). Only Willie Mays (1 HR, 89 AB) and Mike Schmidt (4 HR, 140 AB, one every 35.0) are worse.

But the Cardinals have survived Big Mac's absence to go 37-21 after Aug. 1 because St. Louis' magic baseball potion has somehow turned Will Clark into the Will the Thrill of 1989 again.

Clark hit .345, with 12 homers and 42 RBI, in 51 games as a Cardinal. Which was three more homers and 14 more RBI than he had in 79 games as an Oriole this year. Clark is a professional hitter who also has terrorized the Braves this season (.448, with five homers). But he's not Big Mac -- heck, who is?

"Will Clark has done a good job, but the other guy is an impact player," said one scout. "You have to respect Will Clark. But McGwire has a presence Clark can't possibly have."

5. Will home field matter?
Will the Braves be haunted by losing home-field advantage in this series because of their final-out meltdown Sunday?

They could be -- in all sorts of ways. Their team average is 16 points lower on the road (.264) than at home (.280). Their ERA is slightly higher on the road (4.13) than at home (3.98). Their winning percentage is 95 points lower on the road (.543) than at home (.638).

It also takes something off the Braves' luster as longtime defending champs to lose a game that meaningful in such an unsightly way. It casts another shadow on Rocker. And it's one more small advantage for the Cardinals, a team that proved in the '87 World Series how important just one extra postseason home game can be.

"We're talking about a three-out-of-five series," said one scout. "And I'm a firm believer that when you're playing three out of five, every little edge is a plus. If it's a close series -- and it should be if Kile pitches well in Game 1 -- that could play a big role if it comes down to Game 5."

On the other hand, home-field advantage has had little to do with which team won these division series in the past. The Braves have gone 7-1 in road games in their previous five division series. And back in the '96 NLCS, the Braves had to play an elimination game in St. Louis in Game 5, down three games to one -- and won it 14-0.

So we know Atlanta is eminently capable of winning anywhere. Still, that sea of red in Busch Stadium can look awfully imposing in a big game.

Jayson Stark is a senior writer at ESPN.com



ESPN.com:HELP | ADVERTISER INFO | CONTACT US | TOOLS | SITE MAP | JOBS AT ESPN.COM
Copyright ©2000 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information are applicable to this site. Click here for a list of employment opportunities at ESPN.com.



CLUBHOUSES
Braves
Cardinals

ALSO SEE
Five questions: Mets vs. Giants

A look at the numbers

Series notes: Braves vs. Cardinals