NFL
Scores
Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Message Board
NFL en español
FEATURES
NFL Draft
Super Bowl XXXVII
Photo gallery
Power Rankings
NFL Insider
CLUBHOUSE


ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Sunday, September 9
Updated: September 10, 9:29 AM ET
 
Replacement wrap: Some good, some bad

ESPN.com news services

Replacement officials were in action on Sunday for the first time in NFL history. A game-by-game look at what happened:

Game What happened Penalties/Yds

Lions-Packers
Referee Aster Sizemore never called out the number of the player being penalized and there were two very late flags. Bernardo Harris also recovered Batch's fumble and wasn't touched before getting up and rumbling toward the end zone. He was ruled down at the spot he recovered. "I can tell my buddies that I should have had a touchdown," Harris said. "They robbed me, but that doesn't matter." Detroit:
4 for 57 yds
Green Bay:
4 for 35 yds

Colts-Jets
There were no controversies. Indianapolis:
2 for 10 yds
N.Y. Jets:
3 for 30 yds

Steelers-Jaguars
Officials had little impact, calling three valid unsportsmanlike-conduct penalties and not much else. Pittsburgh:
4 for 29 yds
Jacksonville:
4 for 31 yds

Saints-Bills
Officials were a small factor. They missed what appeared to be Ruben Brown's illegal block on a Saints defender that opened the hole on Peerless Price 31-yard gain off a reverse. The officials also had trouble marching off penalties, twice winding up a yard short. New Orleans:
4 for 35 yds
Buffalo:
4 for 35 yds

Patriots-Bengals
Bengals coach Dick LeBeau challenged an 8-yard touchdown pass to New England's Jermaine Wiggins that cut it to 23-17 with 5:29 left, arguing that he was down before the goal line. Referee John Smith found the replay inconclusive. Smith also decided to review a 15-yard, third-down completion by Bledsoe with 1:23 left on New England's final possession deep in its territory, then ruled the ball was trapped. New England:
3 for 15 yds
Cincinnati:
3 for 20 yds

Bucs-Cowboys
No real problems. The biggest flub was flipping a coin even though President Bush tossed the coin at the White House for the 10 early games. It worked out fine, though, because their coin landed on tails, just like Bush's. Tampa Bay:
6 for 61 yds
Dallas:
4 for 32 yds

Panthers-Vikings
Officials were consistently slow in making calls and marking the spot of the ball. Before one play in the first quarter, referee Wayne McKreight had to run to the sideline and ask someone what down it was. Alos, Mitch Berger's punt bounced near midfield and caused a slight mixup midway through the first quarter when Carolina let it go. It glanced off Minnesota's Harold Morrow, which made the ball dead, but touched a Panthers player and the Vikings jumped on it. Officials signaled Minnesota had recovered but realized the error and reversed the call. Carolina:
7 for 57 yds
Minnesota:
7 for 40 yds

Raiders-Chiefs
A controversial decision late in the first half hurt the Raiders. Charlie Garner made a great catch near the sideline as Jerome Woods slammed him out of bounds on a play that was first ruled a 27-yard gain. But the call was reversed upon review when referee Randall Beesley decided the tackle did not cause both of Garner's feet to go out of bounds. A furious Tim Brown then drew a 15-yard unsportsmanlike penalty, all of which resulted in the Raiders having third-and-17 from their own 46 instead of first-and-10 from the Kansas City 12, and helped the Chiefs take a 14-6 lead into halftime. Oakland:
10 for 106 yds
Kansas City:
4 for 25 yds

Seahawks-Browns
The officials had little trouble in the 9-6 game. Seattle:
1 for 5 yds
Cleveland:
4 for 43 yds

Bears-Ravens
In the second quarter, referee Joseph Rider left his microphone on for three plays, shutting it down only when attempting to announce two penalties. But the officials -- five who went to college in Illinois -- had little impact on the game. "I think the answer I'm supposed to give, for the purposes of fines, is that they did OK," said Chicago cornerback R.W. McQuarters. Chicago:
5 for 56 yds
Baltimore:
6 for 55 yds

Rams-Eagles
The first of two Eagles touchdowns in the fourth quarter came on a reversed call. Cecil Martin was stopped short of the end zone. But referee Al Hynes ruled the ball crossed the goal after watching the replay. The replay showed the play was extremely close, but the Rams' win made it moot. St. Louis:
7 for 45 yds
Philadelphia:
2 dor 20 yds

Falcons-49ers
Falcons coach Dan Reeves thought the replacement officials were too quick with a whistle on the 49ers' game-winning drive in overtime. One play after Tai Streets made a 52-yard reception to put San Francisco in field goal range, Garrison Hearst was stopped on a 2-yard rush up the middle. Officials whistled the play dead, but Atlanta defensive lineman Patrick Kerney popped out of the tackle with the ball. The Falcons insisted it was a fumble, but such a play is not reviewable by instant replay. Atlanta:
3 for 25 yds
San Francisco:
6 for 60 yds

Redskins-Chargers
The officials had little trouble in this victory by the Chargers. Washington:
6 for 69 yds
San Diego:
5 for 49 yds

Dolphins-Titans
Not even a helping hand from the replacement officials could make a difference for the Titans. Chris Sanders had his hands on Dolphins cornerback Patrick Surtain's head and shoulder on a pass down the sideline, but the officials called defensive pass interference for a 34-yard gain on the penalty. Still, Miami forced the Titans to punt. Miami:
6 for 128 yds
Tennessee:
12 for 77 yds




 More from ESPN...
League-wide reaction mixed for replacement referees
There were no game-turning ...

Clayton: Raiders, Chiefs call for regular refs
It took only one ...

Pasquarelli: Replacements weren't a factor
In the spotlight at the ...

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 
Daily email