ESPN.com - NFL/TRAININGCAMP00 - Garcia finding he has huge shoes to fill

NFL
Scores/Schedules
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Weekly lineup

 Thursday, August 10
Garcia faced with following legends
 
 By John Clayton
ESPN.com

STOCKTON, Calif. -- Filling in for Steve Young a year ago was fun for Jeff Garcia. Expectations were minimal -- Garcia was a 195-pound quarterback from Gilroy, Calif., who made a name for himself in the Canadian Football League.

Jeff Garcia
The critics in the Bay Area are already howling about Jeff Garcia.

But now, being the heir to Young's job is a learning experience that isn't going well for Garcia. The pressure is immense. Fans stand on the sidelines of the practice asking each other, "We got to get rid of this Garcia guy?" Already, stories are popping into Bay Area newspapers about a nonexistent quarterback battle among Garcia, veteran Rick Mirer and rookie Tim Rattay.

"You can already see it," wide receiver Terrell Owens said of stories about Garcia's possible demise. "It's in the papers. That hurts me. There is a lot of negative press that he's taking right now. I've read from history that he's a strong person. As receivers, we have to help him out."

Perhaps the first thing he learned being Young's replacement is how to backpedal. A week ago, he answered a question honestly that he didn't feel Young didn't help some of the young 49ers quarterbacks, such as himself. The comments ignited a controversy that forced him to apologize to Young. More than anything, the controversy gave him a blindside hit that he was now a target, not a surprise success story.

"The comments that came out was not how it was intended," Garcia said. "All of a sudden it was a negative situation and something I didn't want to have happen. All of a sudden I had to deal with it and it made a difficult week. My job goes beyond the playing field. It goes to how I handle myself off the field."

He should have known better. In the CFL, he had to follow a legend in Doug Flutie, one of the most popular players in CFL history. Like last year, it was fun filling in, but being the full-time replacement was tough.

"When Flutie got injured, I was able to start nine games and lead our team, Calgary, to the playoffs and eventually win the Grey Cup," Garcia said. "Doug came back for the playoffs and I was back on the sidelines. When Doug left for Toronto, the fans in Calgary expected me to do the same things as him."

Garcia helped direct Calgary to the playoffs and earned Eastern Conference All-Star honors. He was also benched at midseason, making you wonder if Garcia can keep the starting job for 16 games this season. He was benched after five starts last year.

"Early on, I was still learning quite a bit," he said. "I was either not making the right decision or waiting too long to make the right decision. I was also absorbing a lot of pressure for us not winning."

That pressure might be kind compared to this year.

To be the starting quarterback of the 49ers is to be part star, part politician. The 49ers have two decades of excellence from Joe Montana and Young. The standards are high, something that may be impossible for Garcia to achieve. The politics deal with his receivers. Jerry Rice, Terrell Owens and J.J. Stokes have been used to having the ball distributed to them by Young, who was a master at trying to keep his receivers happy. Often, Young would console Rice if he threw a touchdown pass to Owens by saying that he'd get the next one. Rice usually got the next one.

Where Garcia has a problem is that the natural tendency of a young quarterback in the West Coast offense is to throw dump passes to tight ends or backs. Those are easy completions and allow a quarterback to gain confidence.

Those plays don't make the receivers happy, though. In two exhibition games, Garcia hasn't pleased anyone. He hasn't had a touchdown drive. In one game, he didn't complete a pass to a wide receiver.

"The offense is struggling," Owens said. "We've had zero points. We had a game plan to get the ball down the field. That didn't happen. Walking off the field, I felt like we played terrible. We really sucked. Receivers were running routes too deep. Running backs were running wrong routes. The quarterback was holding on to the ball too long."

So how long can Garcia hold on to his job under the mounting pressure.

"Right now, I definitely think I'm confident enough to keep the job all season," Garcia said. "I know I can be the guy who can step in and start and lead this team to the playoffs. I've always been able to lead an offense. I realize I'm also at the elite level now -- things don't come easy."

But criticism comes easier, and Garcia is getting plenty.

John Clayton is the senior NFL writer for ESPN.com.
 



ALSO SEE
Clayton's postcard from 49ers camp

Clayton: Young Niners might make fans restless

Clayton Across America: 31 camps in 28 days

49ers: Time to move on

San Francisco 49ers