| Player | Team | Pos | Analysis |
| Andrea Bargnani | Raptors | F | His 0-for-4 was part of rooks' 4-for-21 night on 3s |
| Jordan Farmar | Lakers | PG | Showed athleticism but struggled to finish plays |
| Randy Foye | Timberwolves | G | Rooks' best (only?) playmaker had seven dimes |
| Jorge Garbajosa | Raptors | FC | Did little after early airball. At least he shaved |
| Rudy Gay | Grizzlies | F | Destoyed on D by D. Lee, but several nice jams |
| Paul Millsap | Jazz | PF | Rookies' best performer had 22, facial on Bogut |
| Adam Morrison | Bobcats | GF | Did OK considering how rest of season has gone |
| Brandon Roy | Trail Blazers | G | Likely ROY was MIA tonight: 2-for-7, six points |
| Marcus Williams | Nets | PG | Somehow shot 2-for-8 in a game with no defense |
| Coach O'Koren | Wizards | Hard to know with what he had to work with |
 |
ESPN Insider John Hollinger's grade: C- |
