| Player | Team | Analysis |
| Gilbert Arenas | Wizards | 23 to start; archaic one-handers left bad taste |
| Damon Jones | Cavaliers | Couldn't back up his big talk. What else is new? |
| Jason Kapono | Heat | Ridiculous final-round 24 crushed competition |
| Mike Miller | Grizzlies | Hard-luck loser bumped out despite 18 in Round 1 |
| Dirk Nowitzki | Mavericks | '06 champ sizzled in Round 1, fizzled in Round 2 |
| Jason Terry | Mavericks | Proof of why set shooters fare better at this event |
Roll over player name for grade
